Wednesday, June 28, 2017

More of decentralized organizations are needed

1. As population grows old, elderly people may have to retire. If elderly people becomes pensioners under a pay as you go scheme, population aging not only reduces the supply of working age population but also increases the costs. Meanwhile, developing countries increase supply of cheap and healthy workers by producing traded final goods. The domestic industries in general as well as those intensively using youth labor may lose competitiveness.

An advanced economy may choose deepening sophistication of the economy in two dimensions - time and space. Some countries like the U.S.A. and the U.K. may pursue spatial expansion of their corporations. It is because they have the global language - English - as their native tongs and the fully convertible key currencies - the US dollar and British pound, respectively - as their own currencies. 

The advantages in language and currency enable domestic firms to exploit the opportunities opened by the supply of cheap labor in emerging market countries. They can also exploit the opportunities provided by automation technology. Consequently, domestic workers with less sophisticated skills tend to be driven out of the traded goods sector in the world. The country need to handle another problem - i.e., industrial hollowing out.

Other countries like Germany and Japan do not have advantages in language, which implies higher costs for internationalizing their services.  

Dornbusch, Fischer, and Samuelson (1977) shed lights on the way forwards for the latter type of countries with aging population to remain competent in the global traded goods sector. The key is to improve productivity of firms in intermediate goods sector. It is a way of moving up the global value chain. Maintaining comparative advantages in producing intermediate goods is important because it helps prevent the firms from being crowded out by the emergence of new industrial powers. 

Firms of emerging countries start with final goods production, which requires less sophisticated technological capabilities. As they accumulate experiences in producing final goods, their 'national learning productivity (Goodfriend and McDermott GM 1998)' improves. The improved national learning productivity enables them to internalize positive spillovers from imported specialized intermediate goods. This means that in order for the advanced country to retain competitiveness its firms producing intermediate goods need to forge ahead through making innovations - i.e., by improving products or processes.

2. Remaining competent in intermediate goods sector entails decentralization in the federalist form of organization. The type of decentralization is necessary for and conducive to an economy's making innovations in intermediate goods. It is made possible by and enhances social cohesion.

Decentralized banking system makes long-term loans to local customer firms' financing investments and innovations. By doing this, it helps owner-managers of the local firms to have long-term perspective in making performances. By lengthening time horizon of local firms as investors, it enables the firms to have long-term normal contracts with employees for employments. With jobs being secured, workers make commitments to their own jobs and thereby to making innovations.

A national development bank can help small regional retail banks in a network banking system finance their long-term loans. It can issue foreign currency-denominated bonds in offshore markets and swap the proceeds into local currency to make on-lending to retail banks in long-term loans. In order to enable the sovereign agency to swap the foreign currency-denominated long-term funds into local currency, the country needs to let the currency fully convertible and freely float as argued by Kim (2017).

3. Germany seems to have succeeded in keeping intermediate goods industries home. Their success is founded upon 'coordinated market economy' inhabited by decentralized banking systems with the federalist form of organization.

4. The United States has come to have 'rust valleys' because its firms expanded businesses globally and became multinational corporations while maintaining centralized or hierarchical form of organization based on shareholder value orientation.

Tuesday, May 31, 2016

Solving structural problems in employment and growth of the U.S.economy through social cohesion

Patterns of employment emerging in the wake of the crisis include startup deficits in employment, widening dispersion of productivity growth among industries, higher job vacancies at a given unemployment rate after the global financial crisis.

1. The share of employment by startups decreased. New jobs are created most by startups. The startup deficits in employment reflects failures of the society. If the society is cohesive enough, it will be able to provide young people with opportunities to develop skills and competence. Companies moved less profitable manufacturing processes abroad while keeping home the high value-added part of the supply chain - research and development, designs, etc. Some moved factories close to markets. Others moved factories to emerging market economies where low-skill workers are in abundance. But, manufacturing factories at home are platform for exposing youths to learn basic skills for production and production-related services. They are platforms for incremental innovation too. Knowledge spillovers between production sites and research centers will be larger if they are geographically located nearby.

2. Productivity of ICTs and finances increased rapidly where that of energy and steels remained lagging further behind. The former has benefited from globalization. Financial integration benefited some banks. US R&D centers have benefited from brain drains in other parts of the world. They make breakthrough-innovations. The latter, industries depending on more or less traditional technologies, has less benefited from globalization. The latter industries faced catching up by those in emerging market economies. Manufacturing moved out of the country. "One of the consequences is political polarization (Professor Autor)."

3. At a given unemployment rate, job vacancy rates are higher after the crisis than before the crisis. The grownup firms demand more of highly skilled workers, which are in short supply because most American youths are learning in Starbucks rather than in manufacturing factories or manufacturing-related service providers. A young person who had no choice but to take temporary job in Starbucks, will not have developed the skills in shortage in the labor markets probably in three years. Labor market flexibility in the short run results in structural unemployment and skill mismatches in the medium run.

The above stylized facts in the US economy evince that the youths are the first to lose opportunity to learn skills and to learn by doing in manufacturing and production sites. Mobility of capital across borders in this case created structural unemployment. This represents mal-adjustments of the U.S. economy, representing a 'non-coordinated' market economy, to globalization especially China shocks.

A clue to enhancing social cohesiveness and innovation capabilities of the economy together can be found in the German 'coordinated market economy.'

Proposition 1: If an economy is built up upon strong social cohesiveness, then it will stay competitive in response to the disturbances in labor markets caused by international integration of trade and finance. Despite facing increased competition in the product markets, employees and employers remain cooperative. Instead of layoff workers, employers continue the company's long-term perspective. The respond to the challenge by coming up with innovations in terms of new products and better processes. Innovation requires time and commitment. Relationship banking provided by community banks will finance the innovative efforts by regional small and medium size enterprises (SMEs).

Proposition 2: Community banking is regional institutional infrastructure. It develops symbiotic relationship with SMEs in the region taking advantage of regional proximity. The community banks help SMEs in the region to remain competitive through improving products and processes. Then financial integration may work for all. Free-fall of labor markets in France and Italy does not necessarily prove that international integration of markets, not of policy, is not good every where and not for every body. It may work for all but with a caveat - only if all preconditions are met. One of the preconditions is development of community banking for SMEs.


* A reflection
BOK International conference "Employment and Growth: Roles of Macroeconomic Policy and Structural Reform" 2016 May 30-21, 2016.